Sign in
in
   
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it."  -Aristotle

About Me

I am a co-founder of Notches, an early stage startup currently based in NYC. We are building a free, open reviews network that anyone can participate in and anyone can build on top of. You can find out more on our official blog.

Read more about my background.

Connect with me on...

Recent Readers

Flickr Photos

 

Warning:

This article is more than 45 days old. Given the speed at which the technology world moves, this post is probably somewhat out of date. Please keep this in mind when reading the post. If this is a tutorial, please check whether you are using the same versions mentioned in the article.

Building an ecosystem around SAP

One of the things Microsoft really gets is how to build a platform, innovating and yet carving out real spaces for their ISVs to play in. Part of this is community involvement, and part of this is the ability to let go of some control. SAP is trying to do the same thing.

We had a chance to meet with Zia Yusuf, Aiaz Kazi, and Mark Yolton today to discuss some of the challenges with building their platform ecosystem. As Zia put it, "it is not a platform until the people say it's a platform."  Their strategy revolves around three primary concepts: Adoption, Co-innovation, and Monetization. 

One of the interesting issues brought up by Michael was around the IP rights. Zia acknowledged that this was a complicated and critical issue, but said it's important to look at different stakeholders and different processes. ISVs building software to be sold on the xApps Hub retain their rights and simply sell through this "glorified directory".  In the Enterprise Services Community, where SAP works with customers and partners to define the WSDL, SAP retains rights - but this is less of an issue because the co-innovation is in the contract, and not the actual construction of the service.  Mark thinks that Intellectual Property law in general is still trying to catch up with the co-innovation enabled by today's technology, and I've discussed plenty of scenarios here in the past where this is the case. On SDN, everything is shared and it's "understood that it is freely shared information."

The next challenge is building a strong ecosystem around enterprise software which is, as everyone here admitted, maybe not the most exciting area.  It appeals to a smaller audience, so their goal is deeper, not broader, involvement.  They are embracing the blogosphere. Currently 2/3rds of the bloggers on SDN are not SAP employees, and they expect this to be more skewed towards the customers and employees in the future. Mark Finnern said SDN blogs are often overlooked.

Ismael suggested a "NetWeaver Lite" that is available free to all, something he had suggested in the past. Zia said that is precisely what the Composition Environment aims to be. There is a free runtime - what they are calling a "lean consumption environment". As an ISV you can build and run, and while they have not announced pricing it is targeted towards the SMB market and individuals. And, as one member of our little corner noted, they managed not to call it Lite, Express, or Essentials.

Only published comments... Sep 13 2006, 02:43 PM by Tim

View related posts

 

Mark Yolton said:

Thanks, Tim, for your interest in the SAP Ecosystem.  You hit the high points.  My only addition would be to invite developers and other technologists to join us on SDN (the SAP Developer Network at http://sdn.sap.com) and for business analysts, solution consultants, and other business process experts to join us in the SAP ecosystem at http://bpx.sap.com.  We're interested in all perspectives and plenty of open collaboration.  

Regards,

Mark Yolton

(the suit on the right...)

September 13, 2006 5:17 PM
 

People Over Process said:

Service Oriented Enterprise - Lessons from Planet Sabre Nice notes on the peopleware challanges of implementing SOA. (tags: via:JamesGovernor sabre soa enterprisesoftware services) SAP confuses bloggers with journalists - Or, How to Get a Lot of Comments

September 14, 2006 12:21 AM
 

James Governor said:

good stuff Tim. regarding the ecosystem I got some great quotes in a visit to walldorf recently from chief operating officer, product technology unit, Industry Solutions.

"You can only lower barriers to entry if you have gravity… You need to be attractive. You need to attract ISVs… of couse only some companies can create successful ecosystems. You need to make sure it makes money. It’s a market mechanism. It has to be the most profitable market though, to be the most successful ecosystem."http://www.redmonk.com/jgovernor/archives/001958.html

that point being blog was way off base, wasn't it. i got a bit roasty there in my comments this morning.

September 14, 2006 3:26 AM
   

Tim said:

Thanks Mark. I'm actually planning on putting together something specific to the SDN community today after I have a chance to walk around the SDN Clubhouse and speak with some community members.

James, the ecosystem thing is tough. I'll talk about it a bit when I post about the Shai discussion, but he definitely recognized the difficulty in "letting go" especially for a company that has always played it close to the vest. It's non-intuitive, but it does work!

September 14, 2006 12:06 PM
 

Loosely Coupled // Tim Marman's Weblog said:

In my last post about the SAP ecosystem , Mark Yolton mentioned in comments that I neglected to mention

September 14, 2006 5:51 PM
 

Loosely Coupled // Tim Marman's Weblog said:

In my last post about the SAP ecosystem, Mark Yolton mentioned in comments that I neglected to mention

September 14, 2006 5:51 PM
 

Alpa said:

Hi Tim,

You have a very cool blog here…loved the content.

U know there is an awesome opportunity for people like you who have ur own blogs n sites…I came across this site called Myndnet.com…it’s a platform for people to buy and sell IT related information. and everytime you sell some information you get paid for it…Good money for people like us in the IT domain. Here the link http://www.myndnet.com/login.jsp?referral=alpa83&channel=al754

Sign up is free…check it out…

You can contact me at my id here  for more questions : barot.alpa@gmail.com

Cheers

Alpa

May 8, 2007 3:07 AM
 

Lucy Gerrario said:

that was pretty lame...

January 28, 2008 11:23 AM
 

Lucy Gerarieo said:

That was great!!!  not...

January 28, 2008 11:25 AM